Online Date Turns Deadly: Onlyfans Model Lures Man To Woods And Shoots Him

  • By Chase
  • Sept. 17, 2025, 5:55 p.m.

A Tragic Setup: From Online Chat to Fatal Encounter

Hey there, darlings, buckle up for a story that’s as chilling as it is heartbreaking. What seemed like a steamy online connection turned into a deadly trap for Matthew Dunmire, a 31-year-old aspiring musician from Cleveland. He thought he was in for a romantic night with a woman he met online, but instead, he walked straight into a nightmare orchestrated by Chelsea Perkins, a 35-year-old OnlyFans model and former adult film actress.

Back in March 2021, Perkins, a U.S. Coast Guard veteran from Alexandria, Virginia, drove 300 miles to Ohio with a dark plan in mind. Authorities later revealed she had accused Dunmire of raping her four years prior, though no charges were ever filed. Her revenge? Luring him to an Airbnb for the night before driving him to the isolated woods of Cuyahoga Valley National Park - and let’s just say, things took a sinister turn.

"This wasn’t a spur-of-the-moment act; it was a coldly calculated plan to end his life," prosecutors stated during the hearing, painting a grim picture of Perkins’ intentions.

The Crime Unfolds: A Shot in the Dark

Deep in the Ohio woods, far from prying eyes, Perkins led Dunmire on a hike past a cemetery and through rugged terrain. Once they were off-trail in a secluded spot, she pulled out a firearm and shot him in the back of the head, according to the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Northern District of Ohio. It’s the kind of plot twist that leaves you speechless - and heartbroken for Dunmire, who had no idea what was coming.

After the fatal shot, Perkins didn’t stick around to face the consequences. She fled the scene, drove to Michigan to get a tattoo of a noose on her forearm (talk about a bold move), and then headed back to Virginia as if nothing happened. But the evidence was stacking up - surveillance footage, text messages, and ballistic evidence all pointed straight to her.

Hikers stumbled upon Dunmire’s body on March 9, 2021, in the national park, and investigators quickly pieced together the chilling story. A search of Perkins’ home turned up three 9mm pistols, one of which had her DNA on it, sealing her fate in this tragic tale.

Justice Served: A Long Road Ahead

Fast forward to May 2023, and Perkins pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and using a firearm during a crime of violence on federal property. Facing up to 25 years, she was sentenced to 22.5 years in federal prison, along with five years of supervised release once she’s out. Restitution for Dunmire’s family is still to be determined, but no amount can bring back what they’ve lost.

In court, Perkins offered an apology to Dunmire’s family, saying she takes full responsibility for her actions. Meanwhile, Matthew’s father spoke of the pain of losing a son and the void left for his grandchildren, reminding us all of the human cost behind this crime. It’s a somber note in a story that started with a simple online chat.

This case is a stark reminder of how online connections can hide dark secrets. As we swipe and chat in the digital age, let’s keep our wits about us - you never know who’s on the other side of the screen. Stay safe out there, loves.

Chase
Author: Chase
Chase

Chase

Chase Morgan brings a fresh voice to celebrity news with his sharp eye, laid-back vibe, and signature wit. Known for his distinct style - think light skin, freeform dreads, and effortlessly cool energy - Chase covers the fast-moving world of OnlyFans, viral influencers, and digital scandals with humor and a bit of an edge. When he’s not breaking the next big story, you’ll find him deep in meme culture or dropping sharp takes on the latest online drama.

Instagram